Stunning Mutiny In Supreme Court Ranks,4 Judges Take On Chief Justice

File pic of AG KK Venugopal

At a hurriedly called press conference at his residence, justice J Chelameswar and three other colleagues said the Supreme Court administration was "not in order" and their efforts to persuade Justice Misra even yesterday morning "with a specific request" failed, forcing them to "communicate with the nation" directly.

In it they mentioned instances of cases with "far-reaching consequences for the nation and the institution" that were selectively assigned by the chief justice without rational "basis for such assignment". "We don't want wise men saying 20 years from now that Justice Chelameswar, Gogoi, Lokur and Kurian Joseph sold their souls and didn't do the right thing by our constitution".

Minister Choudhary, however, had said on December 29 - to a question from Ambika Soni and T Subbirami Reddy on the "Status of Finalisation of MOP for the appointment of the judges" - that "GoI after due deliberations, proposed changes in the existing MoP and the draft MoP was sent to the CJI vide letter dated 22.03.2016. We place it before people of country", Justice Gogoi said.

The responses coming in from over the various quarters are falling in every spectrum of morality, while the justices urged the Prime Minister to intervene in the matter urgently.

Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of India, Dipak Misra will address the media shortly after 2.00 pm. "Democracy can not survive without an independent judiciary", the judge added. The judges had resented against the listing of PIL on Loya before Court No. 10 comprising Justices Arun Mishra and MM Shantanagoudar. We owe a responsibility to the institution and the nation. When the Memorandum of Procedure was a subject matter of a decision of a Constitution Bench of this court in Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association and Anr. vs Union of India, [(2016) 5 SCC 1] it is hard to understand as to how any other bench could have dealt with the matter,"the letter alleged. PM must ensure that the 4 judges & CJI, in fact whole SC come to one opinion & proceed further".


The statement earnestly appealed that the Full Court of the Supreme Court should take up the issues raised by the four judges and find solutions that are consistent with the traditions and conventions of the judiciary pointed out by them and that will preserve the independence of the judiciary.

The hard-hitting remarks against the CJI come on a day when Supreme Court took up for consideration the issue of alleged mysterious death of special CBI judge B H Loya, who was hearing the sensitive Sohrabuddin Sheikh encounter case.

R.S. Sodhi, a retired Supreme Court justice, said the judges' decision to express their grievances openly was appalling. It clearly indicates that the Judges were aware that a solution could not be found within the restricted area because of the external influence of the government.

"Looking at its own flaws is the first step to correcting an institution, to deepening true constitutional democracy", said Karuna Nundy, a Supreme Court lawyer.

The Supreme Court is now hearing a plea to investigate Loya's death, local media said.

Related:

Comments

Latest news

Kamala Mills fire: Candlelight march organised for the victims
Since most hotels and restaurants have sold tickets and invested in New Year events, it is not possible to cancel them, he said. The HRAWI has called on its members to give paramount importance to patrons' safety and observance of all fire safety norms.

Israeli PM backs United States plan for UNRWA fund cuts
However, his recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital and announcement that the U.S. Embassy in Israel will move there have weakened his ability to do this.

Factory Output Growth Jumps To 17-Month High, Inflation Rises To 5.2%
But apparel prices fell for the fourth consecutive month, and airline fares fell 0.5 percent after a 2.4 percent drop in November. These so-called core retail sales correspond most closely with the consumer spending component of gross domestic product.

The Queen's Bra Fitter Loses Contract After Tell-All Book
There was no great personal detail included, yet somehow it's been portrayed to be a kiss and tell like Paul Burrell did on Diana. The Royal Warrant Holders Association said it does not comment on decisions regarding individual Royal Warrants or companies.

European Union summit backs Iran nuclear agreement ahead of Trump decision
President Trump, who openly despises the deal, is soon to decide whether or not to renew sanctions against Tehran. Zarif, seated among smiling European officials, followed by a parade of statements in favor of the deal.

Nintendo Direct Mini Unveils Some Major Titles for 2018
The Switch version brings together both versions and adds outfits from Breath of the Wild for both Link and Zelda . The story mode looks like it'll be fun, though I doubt it will touch the fondly remembered Power Tour on GBA.

Walmart raising starting pay, dishing out bonuses to employees
Every Sam's Club store employs about 150 workers, bringing the total number of affected jobs to about 7,500, the person said. In addition, states have been steadily raising the legal minimum wage, with 14 now at $10-an-hour or more as of this year.

India launches 40th PSLV and 100th satellite
The satellites will be placed into two orbits- thirty of the satellites in an orbit of 550 km, and one 359-km above the Earth. Indian Space Research Organisation to launch Cartosat-2 Series satellite on PSLV rocket from Sriharikota in Andhra Pradesh.

Honda Insight Prototype is ready for its Detroit debut
The Insight's battery pack is located under the rear seats, allowing a full-size boot and 60/40 split folding. Honda Canada expects the Insight to consume an average of 4.7 L/100 km based on NRCan test procedures.

In defense of Donald Trump's mental fitness and accomplishments (2 letters)
Sanders likely will face questions about President Donald Trump's views on the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. The White House issued a response to the Post's report that does not explicitly deny the quote.

Five guy: Sharks' Burns headed back to NHL All-Star Game
This season, Pietrangelo has collected 29 points (seven goals, 22 assists) and a plus-15 rating through 41 games. Burns had a combined 151 points the last two seasons, including 76 last season, a team record for a defenseman.

Local flu-related death reported as virus continues to spread
It's been a busy time for the hospital with all of the people stopping by the emergency room with flu like symptoms. We also reached out to the health departments in Benton, Carroll, Clinton, Fountain and Warren counties.

Harvey Weinstein Attacked at Restaurant in Scottsdale
Reps for Weinstein told Page Six that Weinstein "is still OK and in good spirits" and that no police report was filed. TMZ said the person shooting asked if Weinstein wanted to call the police, though this does not appear on the video.

Japanese astronaut apologises for 'fake news' of height increase
Kanai, who is also a doctor and on his first space mission, seemed surprised himself, even concerned by the initial measurement. Kanai soon followed up his announcement with his concerns that he might not be able to fit in a seat on his flight home .

Kevin De Bruyne would welcome Alexis Sanchez's arrival at Manchester City
City, who are 15 points clear at the summit, return to Premier League action with a tough trip to Liverpool on Sunday. It has been a tough period for four months now. 'We are still in negotiations, ' he added.

Other news