Supreme Court should end partisan gerrymandering

Maps of Kentucky Senate and House districts await attendees at the League of Women Voters of Kentucky's forum on redistricting and gerrymandering on Oct. 3 2017

The justices are hearing arguments Tuesday in a dispute between Democratic voters and Wisconsin Republicans who drew maps that have entrenched their control of the legislature in a state that is otherwise closely divided between the parties.

The court previously heard arguments in the case in November 2016 when it was shorthanded, and failed to issue a ruling.

Initiating suo moto proceedings based on the recent verdict of the Supreme Court in connection with custodial deaths, the first bench comprising Chief Justice Indira Banerjee and Justice M. Sunder said "in terms of the judgment dated September 15, 2017, of the Supreme Court we initiate suo moto public interest petition to identify next of kin of the prisoners who have admittedly died an unnatural death as revealed by the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) during the period between 2012 and 2015 and thereafter for awarding suitable compensation except whom adequate compensation was already been awarded".

The Supreme Court of the United States heard arguments Tuesday for Wisconsin's partisan gerrymandering case.

Gerrymandering has been around for about as long as politics, but Wisconsin's case has an unfamiliar twist. The court has a 5-4 conservative majority. The court concluded that the evidence established that one of the purposes of the redistricting plan - Act 43 - "was to secure Republican control of the Assembly under any likely future electoral scenario for the remainder of the decade, in other words to entrench the Republican Party in power". It's not good for Republicans or Democrats.

State legislative and congressional districts are redrawn every 10 years, following the most-recent US census.

Achieving this normally means dividing districts up along highly irregular lines to ensure that voters from each party are concentrated in the right areas and spread thin in others, as the Washington Post illustrates using a popular explanation adapted from Reddit. Murphy conceded it would be. Republicans gerrymandered legislative district lines so aggressively that in the next election, even though Wisconsin Democrats won 174,000 more votes than Republicans in races for state assembly seats, Republicans won a 60-39 majority in the chamber.

It had been diminishing over time and left for good on December 12, 2000, when the court, in a 5-4 decision, halted the vote-counting in Florida and handed a disputed overtime presidential election to Republican George W. Bush over Democrat Al Gore.


Justice Stephen G. Breyer proposed a five-part inquiry for courts to follow in such cases, while Justice Elena Kagan suggested judges can use the same techniques that states do when drawing the maps for partisan advantage.

But Alito voiced doubt over whether the metrics used to measure gerrymandering, drawn from social science and endorsed by the lower court, were manageable. "What's this court supposed to do, a pinch of this, a pinch of that?" "A pinch of this, a pinch of that?" he asked. Aren't those all textual indications in the Constitution itself that maybe we ought to be cautious about stepping in here? Arnold Schwarzenegger, former governor of California (R), calls on the Supreme Court to "terminate" gerrymandering.

The challengers' new filings relied heavily upon one mootness doctrine - that one party in a dispute is not entitled to scuttle the dispute, just by changing the behavior that led to the fight in the first place.

Democrats are urging the court to consider state legislative district elections, in which voters choose between candidates, as the near-equivalent of statewide proportional elections, in which voters vote for parties, not people.

Namely, attorney David Gersch argued, counts in the Pennsylvania suit that relate to freedom of speech and expression can't be made moot by the U.S. Supremes because the state constitution has broader protections in that area. "That is going to cause very serious harm to the status and the integrity of the decisions of this court in the eyes of the country".

"What incentive is there for a voter to exercise his vote?" "Where does the NLRA say 'in the workplace?'" Ginsburg asked. What becomes of the precious right to vote?

Republicans now represent 13 of 18 congressional districts in Pennsylvania, despite winning about half the statewide votes in the past three elections.

Related:

  • DOJ rescinds policy protecting transgender people from workplace discrimination

    DOJ rescinds policy protecting transgender people from workplace discrimination

    The lawsuit is filed in Washington by two gay rights organizations representing eight transgender USA service members. It's not the first time the Trump administration has broken with its predecessor on how to interpret Title VII .
    Divided Uber board reaches peace with SoftBank, governance deal

    Divided Uber board reaches peace with SoftBank, governance deal

    As of Sunday, Thain and Burns still weren't official board members of the San Francisco-based company, one of the people said. On Aug. 30, media mogul and Uber board member Arianna Huffington posted a happy photo to her Twitter account.
    Woman expecting yoga mat delivery gets $400K worth of oxycodone instead

    Woman expecting yoga mat delivery gets $400K worth of oxycodone instead

    York County drug agents gave Channel 9 photos of the drugs, and the box they came in, shipped from Newport Beach, California. The post office knew she had moved and thought they would do her a favor by delivering it to her new address.
  • Don't expect Vladimir Putin to give up newfound role as OPEC's 'co-pilot'

    Don't expect Vladimir Putin to give up newfound role as OPEC's 'co-pilot'

    The Russian president spoke ahead of meetings with the leaders of key Opec members, Saudi Arabia and Venezuela . OPEC ministers attending the Moscow event said they were considering extending the deal or making a deeper cut.
    Pixel 2 Best Buy Pre-Orders Might Include Google Home Mini

    Pixel 2 Best Buy Pre-Orders Might Include Google Home Mini

    The Google Home Mini is a sleek design with rounded corners to make it look like an ornament and seemingly integrate into a room. That big ticket does include a 12-month subscription for Youtube Red , which would otherwise cost $120.
    Range Rover Sport gets a plug-in hybrid makeover

    Range Rover Sport gets a plug-in hybrid makeover

    The 2018 Range Rover Sport lineup will arrive in Australia in April, with prices starting from $95,100 (excluding on-road costs). And to keeps all other screens alive as well, the sportiest Range Rover can be ordered with up to 12 power outlets.
  • Saudi Arabia invests $1bn

    Saudi Arabia invests $1bn

    Although Chechnya has a population of just over one million, Mr Kadyrov is one of Russia's most influential officials. Lavrov said the Saudi monarch and Putin's meeting saw a "particular focus on Syria , Iraq, Libya and Yemen".
    BSF Camp Near Srinagar Airport Attacked

    BSF Camp Near Srinagar Airport Attacked

    The airport is managed by the Indian Air Force and also doubles as a military base with many attack helicopters based there. Following the attack, all the morning flights were cancelled, and airports were sealed till security clearance.
    Russian Federation  investigation: The 'collusion issue is still open', says Senate intelligence chairman

    Russian Federation investigation: The 'collusion issue is still open', says Senate intelligence chairman

    Burr said the panel wanted to finish its investigation by the end of the year. Burr and the committee's vice chairman, Sen.
  • Germany, England Qualify For 2018 FIFA World Cup

    Germany, England Qualify For 2018 FIFA World Cup

    That isn't their fault. "That isn't their fault so we have to give them the belief and the backing to achieve". But they will give everything they've got for the shirt and they are going to improve over the next few years.
    Las Vegas Shooter Stephen Paddock Gambled For $10000 Per Day

    Las Vegas Shooter Stephen Paddock Gambled For $10000 Per Day

    Stephen Paddock and his partner, Marilou Danley, 62, were regulars at the Starbucks inside the Virgin River Casino in Mesquite. During her American divorce, Marilou Danley listed a downtown Reno unit at the Montage luxury condominium as her address.
    Google Pixelbook Specs And Price Confirmed

    Google Pixelbook Specs And Price Confirmed

    They work closely with the Pixel 2 for pairing and using the Google Assistant , and it can also translate languages on the fly. As for launching the Google Assistant, the Pixelbook features a dedicated key on the keyboard.

Comments

Latest news

Catalan La Liga clubs to join region-wide strike
The region's leaders defied Madrid by holding a banned referendum on independence on Sunday. King Felipe VI threw his support behind the Spanish government.

Prankster held over PM's P45 stunt had legitimate accreditation, say police
But another MP did warn: "The duty is on us to support the leadership with the necessary discipline". The events came as questions over the Prime Minister continue to be asked.

PNE duo in the Republic of Ireland squad
Only victory over group whipping boys Moldova will do for O'Neill's men after two draws last month damaged their qualifying hopes. Asked if McCarthy was ruled out, O'Neill said: "Well, I don't think so, no - and he doesn't want to be ruled out at the moment".

National Weather Service: Mild and sunny all day
Tonight the NWS is calling for a low around 44 with the winds turning to the south, but remaining calm at 5 to 7 miles per hour . Friday night: A 90 percent chance of showers and thunderstorms after 8 p.m., temperature remaining steady around 66.

United Nations fears "further exodus" of Muslim Rohingya into Bangladesh
About 900,000 doses of cholera vaccine are due to arrive this weekend and a vaccination campaign should start on Tuesday.

Red Sox vs. Astros ALDS Preview
Quite a comeback from his only previous postseason - in 2015, he batted just .154 (4 for 26) without an extra-base hit. And if the Tribe are upended in the first round, the Yankees are another team no one really is begging to play.

International Space Station Crew Gearing Up for Three October Spacewalks
Astronauts aboard the International Space Station are performing a spacewalk Thursday to work on parts of the station. The first spacewalk will focus on the removal and replacement of one of the Canadarm2's latching end effectors (LEE).

Christmas Alert: The tomb of original Santa Claus found, claim archaeologists
Santa Claus , has become one of the most popular, gift-giving figures associated with the Christian holiday of Christmas today. Nicholas church , while others claim his remains were smuggled by Demre sailors to Venice or Bari, Italy during the Crusades.

The Next Giant Leap: US Will Return to the Moon, Pence Says
Currently, NASA relies on the Russian space agency, Roscosmos, to transport astronauts to and from the space station. Rather, Pence cites the need to "look beyond the halls of government for insight and expertise".

Ivanka Trump, Donald Trump Jr. were nearly indicted over fraud accusations
Kasowitz stated "I have never made a contribution to anyone's campaign, including Cy Vance's, as a "quid-pro-quo" for anything". None of the investigators on the case reportedly were present.

Catalan president lives outside law - Spain's deputy prime minister
In a rare address to the nation on Tuesday, the Spanish monarch, King Felipe said Sunday's vote was illegal and unconstitutional . The far-left party CUP says Catalonia's regional parliament will consider a declaration of independence from Spain on Monday.

Tom Petty Doc Filmmaker Peter Bogdanovich Recalls an "American Original"
Man, was I lucky, and moreso we were lucky that Tom Petty passed our way and left us a soundtrack more significant every day". Petty's 2014 album Hypnotic Eye , which would prove to be his last release, earned the Heartbreakers their first No. 1.

LA Chargers Hope To End Losing Streak As They Face Philadelphia Eagles
And we just stunk the first quarter of our season. "And it all comes down to his study and preparation". And he was vastly improved from the week before, when he began rotating with Stefen Wisniewski .

Walmart Buys Logistics Startup to Enable Same-Day Delivery in NY
Its current clients - who it will continue to serve, Walmart said - include meal kit companies like Chef'd and Purple Carrot. Faust said NY , where Parcel is based, is the top market for both Jet and Walmart.com due to the density of the population.

Alleged BTC-E Admin and Bitcoin Launderer Will Be Extradited to US
Vinnik, 38, was detained in Greece on July 25 at the request of USA authorities charging him with a number of offenses. Authorities suspect he was ringleader and responsible for alleged laundering activity since 2011.

Other news